Welcome to Tomatoes II Pizzeria
Tomatoes II Pizzeria, located at 1069 Washington Ave in Carnegie, PA, offers a delightful experience for pizza lovers. Renowned for its perfectly crafted crust and well-balanced sauce, this pizzeria has quickly become a local favorite. Customers rave about the consistently delicious offerings, including pepperoni pizza, garlic knots, and their famous cinnamon sugar puffs. The warm, attentive service enhances the experience, with staff going above and beyond to ensure customer satisfaction. Whether you're dining in or carrying out, the welcoming atmosphere and delectable menu make Tomatoes II Pizzeria a must-visit for anyone seeking exceptional pizza in Pittsburgh.
Tomatoes II Pizzeria: Reviews & Ratings
I was trying late night to get Pizza from my favorite place in town that doesn’t deliver and couldn’t figure it out for the life of me... That’s when I saw Tomatoes II PiZzeriA.. It was 1 minute before closing and I put in a Pepperoni Pizza order (I know, I was THAT guy). I called in to make sure it was ok, and the staff couldn’t be nicer... I couldn’t believe that this dude brought it over himself, fixed a price issue with the third party ordering service and have me a free drink (I should have just called).. Amazing service, AND I HAVE A NEW FAVORITE PIZZA IN TOWN!
Tomatoes II pizza in Carnegie is good pizza. The crust is awesome and the sauce is not overwhelmingly sweet. Garlic knots, pepperoni puffs and the cinnamon sugar puffs were all delicious.
I really enjoyed the Pizza and subs at Tomatoes II in Carnegie. I am always on the prowl for the best pizza in Pittsburgh and this place is a gem. Also the owner and his wife were super kind and helpful. Highly recommend.
We ordered a couple hoagies (steak and Italian), pizza, fries, and cinnamon sugar puff things and OMG everything is AMAZING!! These cinnamon puffs are to die for!! My kids are particular about their pizza and they LOVE this, my 6 and 5 year old ate almost the entire large pizza by themselves. Plus the staff was very polite, patient, and kind!! I had to make special orders (like no onions on one thing, plain on another etc) and they still got my order 100% correct. I am sad we don't live in the area because I want to try more of their food, but if we are ever in the area again we will definitely be back!!
This is the best pizza I love it just Devine the man who answers the phone is amazing will be ordering again don’t take my word for it you gotta buy some
Never eaten here before. This was a first. Pizza was the bomb. I will be ordering here again. Good stuff. I did get Italian hoagie, but that’s my lunch tomorrow
The pizza was absolutely awesome! The chicken was perfect, and the green peppers added just the right crunch and freshness. Totally hit the spot. Thank you
I had a great experience at Tomatoes II Pizzeria and I would highly recommend it! The staff was friendly and welcoming. The pizza, especially the pepperoni and broccoli varieties, was absolutely delicious. The crust was perfectly crispy, and the toppings were fresh. I also tried the chicken Alfredo pasta, which was creamy and flavorful. And the wings? Definitely the best I've had in a long time—crispy and flavorful with the right amount of sauce.
Location
-
1069 Washington Ave, Carnegie, PA 15106, United States Hotline: +1 412-745-7474
Welcome to Tomatoes II Pizzeria, a hidden culinary gem nestled at 1069 Washington Ave, Carnegie, PA, where late-night pizza cravings find their cure. With a stellar reputation for both service and flavor, this pizzeria has quickly garnered a loyal fanbase. Get ready to dive into a world of perfectly crafted pizzas, delectable garlic knots, and irresistible cinnamon sugar puffs that will leave your taste buds dancing.
One standout feature of Tomatoes II Pizzeria is its dedicated staff. As noted by patrons, the team goes above and beyond, ensuring that every customer feels valued. A recent review by Charles Knudsen highlighted how a late-night order was treated with utmost care, emphasizing the personal touch the staff brings to their service. This dedication to customer satisfaction ensures that even last-minute orders are met with a smile and the enthusiasm to deliver quality.
The menu features a variety of pizzas, including a classic pepperoni pizza, which has been praised for its optimal crust and balanced sauce that is not overly sweet. One satisfied customer, A A, praised the crust and noted that the pizzeria's garlic knots and pepperoni puffs are equally exceptional. Each bite reflects the commitment to crafting flavors that resonate.
For those seeking variety, the hoagies also shine brightly. Reviewers like Amanda Good rave about the steak and Italian hoagies, describing their experience as “amazing” and “to die for.” It's clear that whether you’re in the mood for pizza or hearty subs, Tomatoes II Pizzeria serves up dishes that keep you coming back for more. And families appreciate the restaurant’s attention to customizing orders – a true testament to their customer-first philosophy.
The warmth of the owner and staff adds to the delightful ambiance of the pizzeria, making each visit feel personable. Abby Wilcox noted how accommodating and kind the owners are, enhancing the overall dining experience. Tomatoes II Pizzeria isn’t just about food; it’s about fostering a community spirit where everyone feels welcome and appreciated.
So, the next time you find yourself in Carnegie, PA, or even if you're dining late in the night, think of Tomatoes II Pizzeria. With a menu overflowing with delicious options and a team ready to satisfy your cravings, you might just discover a new favorite that leaves you dreaming of your next visit.